CR Blog

Symbol: from Pan Am to the Pompidou

Books, Graphic Design

Posted by Mark Sinclair, 5 May 2011, 12:15    Permalink    Comments (15)

Symbol, a new book by Angus Hyland and Steven Bateman, celebrates the beauty of the purely visual mark. We have two extracts from the book that focus on the classic symbols designed for the airline Pan Am and the Centre Georges Pompidou in Paris...

"The idea behind this book," Hyland writes in his preface to Symbol, which is published by Laurence King (£22.50), "is to explore the visual language of symbols according to its most basic element: form." The collected symbols are categorised by visual type, either abstract or representational designs, and include 1,300 examples using circles, dots, crosses, stripes, loops and curves; followed by those that are versions of flowers, objects, animals etc.

"They are laid out for view divested of all the agendas, meanings and messages that might be associated with them in their own customary contexts. Arranged this way," Hyland continues, "the symbols are essentially isolated so that the effectiveness of their composition and impact can be assessed without distraction and so that the reader can enjoy them as a pictorial language in their own right." More information on Symbol can be found on laurenceking.co.uk.

To coincide with the launch of the book, Hyland will also be presenting a talk on symbols at the Design Museum in London on May 18. Details here.

The following extracts make up two of several extended case studies on some of the most celebrated symbol designs.

Pan Am by Edward Larrabee Barnes/Charles Forberg/Ivan Chermayeff, US, c.1955; redesigned by Chermayeff & Geismar, US, 1971

Pan American World Airways was founded in 1927 as a scheduled airmail and passenger service operating between Florida and Havana. With its refined image and famous flying boats, or ‘Clippers', the airline soon became synonymous with the romance and glamour of 1930s air travel.

In the mid-1950s the company announced the arrival of America's first commercial jets with a revamped identity courtesy of New York architect Edward Larrabee Barnes (appointed as Pan American's consultant designer in 1955) and his associate, Charles Forberg. Barnes and Forberg in turn asked Ivan Chermayeff, then on their staff, to redesign the airline's logotype and symbol.

They replaced the existing symbol, a stylized wing and globe motif, with a simplified blue globe overlaid with parabolic lines: a symbol of the drive and ambition that continued to define Pan American's pioneering spirit.

When Najeeb Halaby became chairman in 1970, his desire to breathe new life into the airline prompted an invigorating yet short-lived design programme. Patrick Friesner, Pan American's head of sales and promotion, commissioned work by the period's finest designers including George Tscherny, Rudolph de Harak and Alan Fletcher.

At the core of the programme was a new visual identity designed by Chermayeff & Geismar, the most important element of which was a change of name from Pan American World Airways to Pan Am. A refreshed globe and a new logotype set in Helvetica Medium promoted a cleaner, more modern tone, with the airline's signature colour palette of royal blue still firmly in place.

The most acclaimed applications of Chermayeff & Geismar's identity are the promotional poster series designed in 1971 and 1972: the marriage of evocative photography and minimal type communicates a unique and sophisticated sense of adventure.

Above image from cgstudionyc.com

Halaby was forced to resign in 1972, and his successors wandered away from the clarity of Chermayeff & Geismar's identity, but Pan Am retained the iconic blue globe until its demise in 1991.

 

Centre Georges Pompidou by Jean Widmer, Switzerland, 1977

One of the French capital's finest cultural attractions and one of its most striking architectural landmarks, the Centre Georges Pompidou was the brainchild of French President Georges Pompidou (1911-74), whose ambition to create an original cultural institution in Paris was fulfilled by this groundbreaking endeavour.

Known locally as Beaubourg because of its location in the city's 4th arrondissement, the Pompidou Centre focuses on modern and contemporary creativity, encompassing the visual arts, design, architecture, theatre, music and cinema.

Construction of the centre's idiosyncratic home, designed by Renzo Piano and Richard Rogers, began in 1971 but wasn't completed until 1977, three years after Pompidou's death. Officially opened on 31 January 1977, the Pompidou offers a radical design - with its exposed structural and service elements - and a diverse programme of events and exhibitions that have proved a huge draw to visitors: around 9 million people pass through its doors every year, amounting to over 190 million visitors in just over 30 years.

The architectural treat served up by Piano and Rogers also provided the inspiration for Jean Widmer's symbol: a bold and distinctly modern interpretation of the building with six horizontal stripes intersected by the Pompidou's famous exterior stairway, zigzagging from left to right across the facade. It is an incredibly simple illustration of the building and yet, in capturing the creativity and dynamism of its exposed structure, Widmer expresses the values that led to the foundation of the Pompidou Centre and to its continuing success.

As part of the preparation for our recent Top 20 Logo issue, designer Philippe Apeloig also selected the Centre Pompidou symbol as one of his favourite ever logos. Read about his take on the design, here.

If you missed out on our April Top 20 Logos issue but would still like a copy, we have a few left. Just call +44(0)207 292 3703 to order one.

All images (except for the Pan Am posters) taken from Symbol and republished here with permission. Here are two other spreads from the book:

 

CR's current issue is The Annual, our biggest issue of the year featuring an additional 100 pages of the best work of the past 12 months. If you would like to buy this issue and are based in the UK, you can search for your nearest stockist here. Based outside the UK? Simply call +44(0)207 292 3703 to find your nearest stockist. Better yet, subscribe to CR for a year here and save yourself almost 30% on the printed magazine. If you subscribe before Wednesday April 27 you will receive the May issue/Annual as part of your subscription.

 

15 Comments

Symbol / one's to have!
badinicreateam
2011-05-05 13:50:02


What a great tool for inspiration and a fascinating look at the evolution of what types of looks have manifested over the years. The evolution of image.
Chuck
2011-05-05 14:16:35


Looks awfully similar to Michael Evamy's Logo.
Daniel
2011-05-05 14:34:30


looks like a great one for the coffee table. some fantastic work, very relevant to the recent CR articles on branding too.
thinker
2011-05-05 14:47:36


What Daniel said.

Having seen the book (I presume) can CR shed any light on similarities/differences before I end up spending money buying Logo again?
Ed
2011-05-05 15:05:52


@Daniel, Ed
Yes, I have a proof copy of Symbol here. The two books of course have overlaps, but Symbol explicitly looks at purely graphic marks (so no 'logotypes' or 'wordmarks' e.g. FedEx, Coca-Cola, IBM etc). They both boast around 1,300 images, so there should be plenty in Symbol that you won't find in Logo (which came out in 2007 – and is a fine book in its own right).
CR Mark Sinclair
2011-05-05 15:23:01


This looks awesome. I gotta get a copy stat. Great design reference material.

Perfect - completely illustrates beautifully what I share with other designers and clients on a regular basis. Great focus: "to explore the visual language of symbols according to its most basic element: form."

The symbol. Exactly. Most important tool.

Cheers!

JT
Brandmaven
@stoneboard
JT Potts
2011-05-05 15:26:47


@Mark
Fair dinkum.
Daniel
2011-05-05 15:31:41


...'to explore the visual language of symbols according to its most basic element: form."
It doesn't look like that to me, it looks like a thoughtless grouping of like with like. That is not exploration, it is lazy.
Miles
2011-05-06 00:14:20


I don’t think the Pompidou logo has anything to do with Switzerland. Even if Jean Widmer was born in Frauenfeld, he began his career in Paris in 1953 and kept working in this city ever since.
Bureau l’Imprimante
2011-05-06 09:04:12


Looks Great

Amazon £15.75. Bargain!
Ian C
2011-05-06 12:10:38


Looks good. The case studies sound very interesting, may be worth it for them alone
Agency
2011-05-07 10:01:21


I'm sure this will sell well. (and if Angus did it then it will be well designed)

I'm sure it's a thorough archive of logos past. 

But...

It does seem a shame that as a profession who fuel tomorrows branding, we seem to so deeply delight in the past achievements of the brands that simply survive rather than those that genuinely move the practice of branding on. 

Pan Am with all it's retro chic and knowingly reissued vinyl satchels is an easy inclusion — but did it really do anything innovative? Or is it simply a comfy sofa of reassuringly cosy logo nostalgia. 

It's about as useful as the Nike Swoosh. Any symbol with that amount of exposure will etch itself onto societies retina and consciousness. 

Equally did the Pompidou branding leap as far ahead as the radical architectonic mindset behind the building?

I'd say not. 

It's just another logo. Stamped into the back of a cow. 

Same old application. 

Those ads are a rather dull really. And not that effective. Cover the logo and they could be anything. From anyone. 

In fact I'd go as far as to say the Pompidou symbol is also simply a convenient minimalist geometry that did little to add to a more progressive approach to creating compelling visual brand identities for products, services and organisations. 

For me, this book serves as an example of how things have started to move on. (however slowly in some parts of the design fraternity)

These symbols may be romantic when viewed through the rose tinted glasses of 'the good old days' of graphic design. But they bear little resemblance to the new branding landscape we are experiencing today. 

I'm not knocking this book. Archives are useful and important (I' sure SomeOne will order it soon!)

I'm simply saying that we should be as keenly devouring ways creativity has introduced game changing approaches to branding — if we are to really create new design work that merits being included in the equally elegantly designed archives of the future. 
Simon Manchipp
2011-05-11 23:24:30


@Simon Manchipp are you for real?
Curator
2012-01-19 14:51:40


Funny,

"In fact I'd go as far as to say the Pompidou symbol is also simply a convenient minimalist geometry that did little to add to a more progressive approach to creating compelling visual brand identities for products, services and organisations." - Simon Manchipp
2011-05-11 23:24:30

You'd do well to look again at your 'Torch Doha' 'logo' before you cast aspersions on the very elegant Centre Georges Pompidou symbol.
Curator
2012-01-20 10:23:43


Tell us what you think

What happens with my feedback?

We no longer require you to register and have a password in order to comment, simply fill in the form below. All comments are moderated so you may experience a short delay before your comment appears. CR encourages comments to be short and to the point. As a general rule, they should not run longer than the original post. Comments should show a courteous regard for the presence of other voices in the discussion. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments that do not adhere to this standard.

Share This — Social Bookmarking

Get the RSS Feed
NULL